SOTW Feedback & Suggestions

Emeralda

Pistis Sophia
#2
Why, did something happen? So far I think you were doing your job well, and the early comics were a nice touch to actually make me enter SotW from day 1.
 
#3
[quote name='Emeralda']Why, did something happen? So far I think you were doing your job well, and the early comics were a nice touch to actually make me enter SotW from day 1.[/QUOTE]



Nothing really. I just thought that a feedback/suggestions thread would be useful, given that I've been a bit confused over some themes (eg. Black & White, Chosen Stock). Anyhow, feedback and suggestions are always helpful, so I decided to ask for them.
 

Emeralda

Pistis Sophia
#6
Rawr, check the current SotW voting. I'm so pleasantly surprised that all the sigs have similar sizes and ratios. I hope this tendency keeps up.
 

VivaLaDementia

Yea, Its been a ride...
#7
[quote name='Emeralda' timestamp='1307196872' post='146068']

Rawr, check the current SotW voting. I'm so pleasantly surprised that all the sigs have similar sizes and ratios. I hope this tendency keeps up.

[/quote]

I need Kaze to help me revolt D':
 

Emeralda

Pistis Sophia
#8
Great job Hadriel, from now on people should just pick nice wallpapers, crop them and put them as SotW entries, because apparently that's all that's needed to win a SotW.
 
#9
>_>

Well, would you rather I disqualify them from the onset or leave it to the voters to decide whether an entry is deserving of the title or not during the voting? I can forsee lots of QQing and complaints if I were to adopt the former system.
 
#12
Well, Emmie is right in saying that there's a limit to how little you can work on a stock and expect to win. It's unfair if someone just finds a nice stock and uses it instead of working on effects more like others might on a worse stock.
 

~Kitty~

Kitty pawns all!
#13
well I kinda enjoyed the text nya~

But yeah if the original pic stays original there is no point in submitting it...

its basically copy paste add some simple stuff and done...
 

Canabary

Administrator
#19
Well, it was disqualified because you didn't provide a stock URL (which was stated in the rules).
Eh, you need to kniw the urls? I have no idea, most of them are part of my extensice stock archive on my computer, but eh, I'll see if I can't travk it down then...