Assassin's Creed AG Discussion Thread [Game Over]
- Thread starter godofwar7
- Start date
Honestly, the opening paragraph makes it seem like the assassins are good, since they are addressing us as if we are their allies, however the group goals clearly point at Templars + City Guard vs Assassins, which makes me think Assassins are bad.
However, in the end I'm going with Templars are bad due to their second part of the goal "non-templars' numbers lower then yours". Thats the typical assassin goal and that also means there is a small amount of Templars.
Kind of screwed up balance-wise that Templars and City Guard can team up to both win the game, but then again we don't know if there is a counter-balance in the assassin's favor with that.
However, before people moronically jump the gun, it is very clear that the City Guard and Templars might not be on the same side at all. The Templars can easily just decide to kill them off, so view the City Guard as Neutral.
However, in the end I'm going with Templars are bad due to their second part of the goal "non-templars' numbers lower then yours". Thats the typical assassin goal and that also means there is a small amount of Templars.
Kind of screwed up balance-wise that Templars and City Guard can team up to both win the game, but then again we don't know if there is a counter-balance in the assassin's favor with that.
However, before people moronically jump the gun, it is very clear that the City Guard and Templars might not be on the same side at all. The Templars can easily just decide to kill them off, so view the City Guard as Neutral.
Again, we should stop saying these things now.
If everyone assumes the City Guard will join the Templars (when they do not have to), we will force them to join the City Guard and become assassins -> Thus boosting the number of assassins.
Do not alienate the City Guard, if anything we should reach out to them to get them on our side before the assassins Templars do.
@ Crestham - No, The goal is public:
Sure Assassins have to fear the City Guard, but everyone else does not (Unless your on the wanted list).
They are clearly made to be a neutral role, but they will be pushed to join the assassins Templars (By Assassins I meant Templars, forgot that there is a group called Assassins here) if we judge them to be bad on Day 1. We can not make such a moronic mistake on Day 1 or it will severely hurt us later on in the game.
If everyone assumes the City Guard will join the Templars (when they do not have to), we will force them to join the City Guard and become assassins -> Thus boosting the number of assassins.
Do not alienate the City Guard, if anything we should reach out to them to get them on our side before the assassins Templars do.
@ Crestham - No, The goal is public:
Sure Assassins have to fear the City Guard, but everyone else does not (Unless your on the wanted list).
They are clearly made to be a neutral role, but they will be pushed to join the assassins Templars (By Assassins I meant Templars, forgot that there is a group called Assassins here) if we judge them to be bad on Day 1. We can not make such a moronic mistake on Day 1 or it will severely hurt us later on in the game.
Right now they just have to kill the assassins - Which means they are more likely to join the Templars, yes?
However, they don't have to be against the citizens and neutrals. Which means they will only focus on the assassin group, leaving the general public alone.
If we push them away in the public eye, they will join the Templars and aid them completely, they will not care who they kill anymore.
However, if we accept them generally (Obviously don't give out assassin names), then they might not team up with the Templars.
Thats my point - They don't have be against the citizens and neutrals unless we force them to by assuming they are automatically going to aid the Templars.
However, they don't have to be against the citizens and neutrals. Which means they will only focus on the assassin group, leaving the general public alone.
If we push them away in the public eye, they will join the Templars and aid them completely, they will not care who they kill anymore.
However, if we accept them generally (Obviously don't give out assassin names), then they might not team up with the Templars.
Thats my point - They don't have be against the citizens and neutrals unless we force them to by assuming they are automatically going to aid the Templars.
Yeah they are. Unless they are smart enough to get enough the neutrals to help them out early on.
However, if we generally assume City Guard = Templar, do you think they will care about any of the non-assassins anymore?
Citizens and Neutrals don't have to be on their hit list (obviously unless your on the wanted list, but thats more of your own fault and a special case), but if we assume they are just going to join the Templars, they won't care about killing the citizens and neutrals anymore.
Thats my point. We don't need to make more enemies then we already have in this AG, and comments like "City Guard and Templars vs Everyone" will just cause more trouble for us to deal with later on. Which is why I said consider the City Guard a Neutral group (unless your an assassin obviously)
@ Shadow - Meh, theres a good chance the Templars will go after Kitty on day 1 since he is a merchant, so we won't see much of him after that lol xD (Sorry Aker, the truth hurts)
However, if we generally assume City Guard = Templar, do you think they will care about any of the non-assassins anymore?
Citizens and Neutrals don't have to be on their hit list (obviously unless your on the wanted list, but thats more of your own fault and a special case), but if we assume they are just going to join the Templars, they won't care about killing the citizens and neutrals anymore.
Thats my point. We don't need to make more enemies then we already have in this AG, and comments like "City Guard and Templars vs Everyone" will just cause more trouble for us to deal with later on. Which is why I said consider the City Guard a Neutral group (unless your an assassin obviously)
@ Shadow - Meh, theres a good chance the Templars will go after Kitty on day 1 since he is a merchant, so we won't see much of him after that lol xD (Sorry Aker, the truth hurts)