Mafia AG: The Villagers DT [GG]
- Thread starter Crestham
- Start date
- Status
The assassin wouldn't use the public lynch day 1 to kill an extra few goodies. Unless they have balls of steel, especially since the goodies will be hunting down anyone midly suspicious for the stake.
They might have jumped on the bandwagon if they saw it running though, so the suspicion is anyone that jumped after the original Shepard.
I'd guess the 2nd or 3rd player. I'll go check the voting thread.
I'd say we should looking into the bladefellow. Seems like a lurker that just saw a goodie being lynched and wanted to make sure it happened.
Emmie's suspect too on this, though she dosn't fit the criminal profile of an assassin atm.
They might have jumped on the bandwagon if they saw it running though, so the suspicion is anyone that jumped after the original Shepard.
I'd guess the 2nd or 3rd player. I'll go check the voting thread.
I'd say we should looking into the bladefellow. Seems like a lurker that just saw a goodie being lynched and wanted to make sure it happened.
Emmie's suspect too on this, though she dosn't fit the criminal profile of an assassin atm.
Of course. I didn't expect you to lurk, however you can never be to careful. A mention typically gets a post, though sometimes I just mention people reading the thread who planned to post anyway. Happens, but I rather be careful~
Well I wasn't going to lynch Noex at first, but he is acting beyond odd to me. Even ignoring the GM lynching stuff from earlier as a joke, just strikes me as odd. However, now I have some thinking to do since Moi's reply was terrible and makes me think moi just didn't care at all about randomly killing someone.
Well I wasn't going to lynch Noex at first, but he is acting beyond odd to me. Even ignoring the GM lynching stuff from earlier as a joke, just strikes me as odd. However, now I have some thinking to do since Moi's reply was terrible and makes me think moi just didn't care at all about randomly killing someone.
eh... random vote is random. There were several no votes ahead of me and I wanted to break from that. Sure, it was a stupid move, especially with no information to go on. I just scanned the vote thread, now I see you're right, it wasn't sheeping, the others who voted for nico happened to have other reasons.
I for one believe her. If anything, it's the people that sheeped after that are suspicious, like I said a little bit ago.
I highly doubt the assassins would be bold enough to try and get an extra kill with the lynch day 1. Day 2 maybe, day 3 you can expect it as they get bolder.
But it's the start of the game, and the assassins will undoubtedly be playing it safe.
At worst, they may be an opertunist, and sheeped the vote.
It's entirely possible that they didn't even want to vote in order to not bring suspicion, or the eyes of the players.
I'm scanning the post for anyone who wanted to get the least exposure possible, hence why even though Noex is acting strangly, I doubt he's an assassin as well.
It just doesn't logically fit what the assassin would do.
I highly doubt the assassins would be bold enough to try and get an extra kill with the lynch day 1. Day 2 maybe, day 3 you can expect it as they get bolder.
But it's the start of the game, and the assassins will undoubtedly be playing it safe.
At worst, they may be an opertunist, and sheeped the vote.
It's entirely possible that they didn't even want to vote in order to not bring suspicion, or the eyes of the players.
I'm scanning the post for anyone who wanted to get the least exposure possible, hence why even though Noex is acting strangly, I doubt he's an assassin as well.
It just doesn't logically fit what the assassin would do.
This is what I'm on edge about. We have such expectations about what assassins would and won't do these days, doing something such as starting a lynch on day 1 has become a perfect cover for an assassin. I theorize that its only a matter of time before that happens, if it hasn't happened already in this game. Thats why I'm trying to avoid discounting a player's actions just because it doesn't fit the typical assassin profile.
I've got my eye on the Blade guy. He fits the profile I constructed perfectly.
Appeared out of nowhere, voted, and disapeared. I can't find any of his posts on the thread.
My guess:
He's an assassin, who was planning on laying low. And he came out for one of 2 reasons:
On seeing that Nico could have been voted, chose to follow the vote through to earn an extra kill
Or
To protect Seraph.
If seraph was an assassin, his assassin buddies MUST appear and save him, since everyone else was going no-vote.
Blade and Seraph are my theories.
Also, MW, I get the typical reverse thinking I'm doing will eventually become a catch 22 for the assassins. Do it or don't.
But I know noex, and everything he's done has fit his character. He isn't acting differently then he does normally, and I don't think that he'd think of voting ahead of everyone, as the assassin.
Appeared out of nowhere, voted, and disapeared. I can't find any of his posts on the thread.
My guess:
He's an assassin, who was planning on laying low. And he came out for one of 2 reasons:
On seeing that Nico could have been voted, chose to follow the vote through to earn an extra kill
Or
To protect Seraph.
If seraph was an assassin, his assassin buddies MUST appear and save him, since everyone else was going no-vote.
Blade and Seraph are my theories.
Also, MW, I get the typical reverse thinking I'm doing will eventually become a catch 22 for the assassins. Do it or don't.
But I know noex, and everything he's done has fit his character. He isn't acting differently then he does normally, and I don't think that he'd think of voting ahead of everyone, as the assassin.
What I put in bold, you hit right on the nail cause it is very true. No assassin would risk themselves like that. However, it is that kind of generalization that could burn us in the ass because much like this game maybe the villagers are doing the exact opposite in thought as well?
I'm guessing more likely than not though that you are right, no way would an assassin risk shepherding. They are always wolves in sheep skin. Right?
I'm guessing more likely than not though that you are right, no way would an assassin risk shepherding. They are always wolves in sheep skin. Right?
[MENTION=1507]Geoff[/MENTION] If Bladewind is an assassin as you said, and if what Viva said earlier about the assassins adopting a different strategy (i.e. going for a D1 lynch) then maybe this fits the bill. But I see now this is more unlikely to happen. Still, never know...
Whether I was right or wrong above, it's possible that he was pretending to be behind all the action when he actually was aware of exactly what was going on...
Whether I was right or wrong above, it's possible that he was pretending to be behind all the action when he actually was aware of exactly what was going on...
Hmm... I'm willing to go along with blade for a lynch today, though that does not change my views on Noex at all.
As far as I know, blade hasn't posted yet today and just went along with Emmie's vote for Nico. The reasoning isn't terrible, but Geoff's idea about blade protecting Seraph sold me on it. Thats a big gain if its true and lynching blade would prove it.
Also - I think we should considering the fact that Auron/Queen could be a baddie. There were only 2 actions yesterday, one was the lynch and the other was a kill from the villagers. Do we really think the villagers only have 1 ability? I don't think thats likely, which makes me think an inactive or person who didn't have time to properly send in an ability could be among the villagers.
Queen hasn't posted yet at all and as far as I know, isn't active. Auron said he wouldn't be active at all yesterday, but he hasn't posted yet at all today. He typically has a butt-ton of things to say.
As far as I know, blade hasn't posted yet today and just went along with Emmie's vote for Nico. The reasoning isn't terrible, but Geoff's idea about blade protecting Seraph sold me on it. Thats a big gain if its true and lynching blade would prove it.
Also - I think we should considering the fact that Auron/Queen could be a baddie. There were only 2 actions yesterday, one was the lynch and the other was a kill from the villagers. Do we really think the villagers only have 1 ability? I don't think thats likely, which makes me think an inactive or person who didn't have time to properly send in an ability could be among the villagers.
Queen hasn't posted yet at all and as far as I know, isn't active. Auron said he wouldn't be active at all yesterday, but he hasn't posted yet at all today. He typically has a butt-ton of things to say.
- Status