SOTW #4 - Voting

[Hadriel]

What a surprise! We've got a whopping 9 entries for this week's SOTW! Thanks to all the entrants!



As always, make sure you take a look at the voting rules before voting!



Theme:

Black & White





Entry #1

Stock







Entry #2

Stock

The designer of this entry wishes for all the voters to first see this video, which will provide an insight into the signature's relevance to the theme:

Spoiler

[youtube]HAfFfqiYLp0[/youtube]

Entry #3

Render







Entry #4

Reference used for drawing







Entry #5

Stock







Entry #6

Render







Entry #7

Stock







Entry #8

Render 1

Render 2







Entry #9

Stock





Note: One entry has been disqualified because the entrant failed to submit a URL of a stock or render/background with her entry.

​

 

[VivaLaDementia]

Well, if I was to ignore the theme, Entry 2 would have won for me, but I can't in good faith do it since there are clearly shades of reds and browns in there. I'm a bit shocked its not disqualified tbh.



Entry 1 almost got it for me, but using the render in front of the render like that just me go wtf >__<"



Anyway, Entry 6 GMV - Sure its the 3rd best in skill, at least to me, but it followed the theme and wasn't weird in composition, so it gets my vote.

 

[~Kitty~]

Entry 1 or 7?



hmm...



i think my vote goes to 7. cause i like the effect.



Entry 2 is awesome. But i see traces of red >.>



Entry 3 is grey over white or black



Entry6 caught my eye at 1st but it was also grey than white



well good works people

 

[Hadriel]

Rawr, how come it suddenly closed like that? Geez.

 

[Emeralda]

#1 greyscale (although slight)

#2 greyscale (even more than just greyscale)

#3 greyscale

#5 greyscale

#6 greyscale

#7 greyscale (although slight, and could have been avoided)

#8 greyscale

#9 greyscale



#4 wins it and gets my vote. Not only did it follow the strict theme, but is also quite original. It would have used a border to show that it's a tag though >.>

 

[Hadriel]

Oh yes, just to clarify: The entries are based on the entrant's interpretation of the theme. Please don't vote/not vote for an entry just because it's not black and white.

 

[Wwgeaf]

Vote goes to 9

I thought it had a really nice flow in the sig

 

[Archerguy]

i see all of them

go to watch the vid

and read the whole lyric of #2

still don't get the meaning :/



so maybe i'll skip #2 because well hard to understand

vote go to entry #5



The main object is cool, monochromatic, mysterious, and has quite nice mirrored shadow

 

[Murasaki Cho]

Entry #7 GMV.



The closest to black and white but not that plain.

 

[Sanae]

Entry 6 GMV



Although, there is some grey in it, it still looks good ^__^ I like the saturation (?) as well ^^

 

[Crestham]

Entry #7 GMV



I like it.

 

[godofwar7]

#7 GMV because its simple but dynamic.



#1 was nice until i saw the render placed on bottom right corner of the render.



#5 is also nice, but the symmetry is boring.

 

[Lovely.]

#7 GMV, though I thought monochrome was diff from b&w but still one of the best in the bunch.♥

 

[Kaze Araki]

[quote name='VivaLaDementia']Well, if I was to ignore the theme, Entry 2 would have won for me, but I can't in good faith do it since there are clearly shades of reds and browns in there. I'm a bit shocked its not disqualified tbh.[/QUOTE]

Entry 2 GMV, precisely for being a bad ass signature and getting away with it.

 

[Cid]

Entry 7 GMV. It looks pretty awesome.



I like its use of err.. vector lines and how the salient image isn't in the exact middle.