SOTW #7 - Voting

Status
Not open for further replies.
godofwar7

godofwar7

Active Member
#2
#2




godofwar7 says:



I say both should be disqualified for not being typography only :[



There's a difference between having Typography as a focal and doing a Typography tag.



#2 GMV, because they seemed to somewhat understand that, but for w/e reason put a bird in there.

​
 
Lovely.

Lovely.

Hiatus-Land
#3
#3
Ummmmmmmm, GMV #2 I guess..... Both really aren't what I think of when I think of typography.... But the first one doesn't have enough text, the 2nd is better but the bird and all the negative space kinda ruin it.... But still #2 has the theme better. <3
 
M

Maria.

→Donut Vampire
#8
#8
Such appalling entries. :/

In fact both entries deserves to be disqualified for not following the theme.



But, #2 GMV. Reasons are stated already so there isn't a need.



Tip for #2: It'd be more pleasing if you made the bird using text only to form it.



Side suggestion: Technical themes seem to go off most of the time(e.g SOTW-depth and this one). So I suggest that we do less technical themes but I know for the fact that it is boring that way. :/

Again, this is just my opinion and it's highly based from the previously held SOTWs in this site.
 
V

VivaLaDementia

Yea, Its been a ride...
#9
#9
I do agree with GOW and Maria, If your going to make a Typography Only theme, enforce it. Its a bit disappointing to see this sort of thing happen again after the B&W theme event.



Anyway, 2 GMV since its closer to the theme and looks better.

As mentioned by Maria, it would look a lot better if the bird was made in text-only.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.