I won't go as far as saying I have any proof, and that this is just my intuition, but the first theory was based on when you told me about Minerva, thus I suspect that and from the ending of AC Brotherhood, there is an secret sub faction that more or less "controls everything from the shadows". Kinda like keepers, but then again my imagination and thought process is very different from Goddo, so if he actually made it I will hug him, but as I said, this is only theory. I was hoping to use Shadow to investigate prime suspects for my theory, but he's now dead, and you were one of the leading characters in the chapter Viva, also a person I suspect for something, thus I got to the conclusion that you wanted the investigator gone. Since it was quite obvious from my point of view that Shadow was not lying, and it would have never come into light if it wasn't for Graham shouting it out. If my memory serves me correct, Shadow also commented that his plan wasn't for it to happen the way it did, and one of the reasons he was lynched for was "he have done this before".
I had no reason to want the investigator gone. There are others out there as well, who I'm sure will be willing to help you with your theory. I know an investigator who I'm sure would help, but I shall tell you that privately.
He was not lynched because he did this before. I defended him at first by saying that in his defense, that his nature is to go public with a rolesheet (though only from 1 AG to be fair).
However, when it came to the secondary group, that struck me as very, very odd. I didn't see a point for a sub-group in the Templar faction, since those conspirators were all Templars. Templars' goal is hard enough, they don't need an internal affair to divide them even further - Thats a poorly designed game mechanic that I wouldn't expect GOW to use.
Then, Zombehs' items not appearing was a bit odd as well. I thought maybe it wouldn't show up, but then when I spoke to GOW about items, it made it seem more likely that the item should show up. Hence why I was confused more.
2 Flaws (That I believed were flaws) in his argument made me distrust the information.
If Noex was still alive, I would be lynching him and not lynching Seraph (I would try to get people to attack Seraph though, since Emmie gave me a valid reason for her lack of posting).
However, the situation I'm in says that the most suspicious is Seraph. Therefore, that is what I brought up. I was patient. I was more then willing to listen to a reason why I misunderstood Seraph. But no logical answer was given and the behavior was how I would expect a baddie to react, therefore I started the lynch.
I'm sorry you believe me to be bad. However, I can't disprove that I don't belong to secret faction that you don't even have proof exists yet. I would expect my actions to appear logical and in the best interest of the public, but if you don't view it as such, please tell me what you think I can do to do it better. Despite how it looks, I am trying to do what I believe is best for the public, and to me that is lynching the most suspicious person. And, despite your accusations, I know your not bad (Just to be clear), which is why I'm willing to help you find a new investigator to aid you, I just believe your accusation is misguided is all - which is why I am trying to clear it up now.
Edit: Blade, if you want to vote me, use a real reason please. I hate when votes become jokes like "I don't like this person" or "They are creepy".
